Pennzoil vs Valvoline Motor Oil: Who Is The Best?

So you want to change your motor oil, because, well, it’s time. Based on the kind of engine in your car and the model, the manufacturer advises using synthetic or conventional motor oil. Today, you discover that motor oil is available in a variety of types and brands, including Pennzoil and Valvoline. You are now unsure which offers the best quality and value for your money between Pennzoil vs Valvoline.

You’re in luck! We’ve already done the research and comparison of Pennzoil and Valvoline synthetic oil for your convenience. The primary fuel for a smooth-running engine and parts is motor oil. It affects an engine’s overall safety and performance. Valvoline synthetic mix is a well-known oil today, and the business operates a top-notch engine lab. Pennzoil is an American oil company that also offers security and high-performance cars.

What distinguishes Pennzoil from Valvoline, and which oil is better for your vehicle?

Your choice of motor oil should take into account a variety of aspects, including viscosity/grade and OEM standards, as using the incorrect motor oil can result in your automobile engine operating inefficiently. We will contrast Pennzoil and Valvoline synthetic oils in this blog post to determine which is the best choice for a car or a truck.

Overview of Pennzoil

After 40 years of research and development, Pennzoil was the first motor oil made solely from natural gas. The basic oil for Pennzoil synthetic motor oil, which is blended at the 3,500 US mixing plants, is made using an unique gas-to-liquid method.

indycar pennzoil vs valvoline

Before distribution, Pennzoil inspects every product to ensure high quality, resistance, and efficiency.

Now, what are the pros of Pennzoil?

  • Has improved fuel efficiency
  • Offers improved wear protection
  • Extremely good results in any temperature
  • The clever formula of Pennzoil improves emission protection while controlling high-temperature oxidation.
  • The oil also possesses the API SN Plus and ISLAC GF-5 certifications and continuously inhibits the buildup of sludge.
  • Along with the affordable prices, many find the Pennzoil Lubrication Limited Warranty to be tempting.

About Pennzoil Platinum

The flagship item from Pennzoil, Pennzoil Platinum, has different variants: conventional oil, full synthetic and high mileage. The latter is made especially for vehicles with more than 75,000 miles on them! Pennzoil is the oil for your automobile if it’s an older model or if you drive a lot of miles annually.

This motor oil is designed to fulfill all OEM and industry criteria and comes in a variety of grades and viscosities. Platinum can be used on almost any vehicle that is designed for the grades it comes in; for example, 5w20, 0w20, and similar grades.

Key Qualities of Pennzoil products

  • The finest motor oil in general is Pennzoil Ultra Platinum Full Synthetic 5W-30. Your car’s engine receives more power and better protection thanks to Pennzoil synthetic 5w-30.
  • We also advise using Pennzoil 10W-30 high mileage motor oil for cars with more than 75,000 miles on the odometer in high mileage vehicles, SUVs, light trucks, and passenger vehicles. It prevents the buildup of harmful substances like sludge.
  • Additionally, because Pennzoil – 550045214 conventional oil avoids metal-on-metal contact, no other conventional oil provides higher wear prevention. In addition, Pennzoil oil changes are considerably less expensive than those at Valvoline.

Overview of Valvoline

The only company offering true quick oil changes is Valvoline. People who are working a lot and don’t have time for automobile services would gain from this. It will aid in reviving the aged engine and maintaining satisfactory performance. Additionally, Valvoline synthetic oil changes are less expensive than those of other brands.

valvoline shop in pennzoil vs valvoline

What about the pros of Valvoline products?

  • The top-of-the-line Valvoline conventional oil is considered as the standard in the industry.
  • It is offered in a variety of viscosities, from 10W-30 to SAE 50.
  • The additional detergents offer improved resistance against sludge buildup.
  • Due to improved oxidation management and prevention of oil thickening, the combined additives prevent motor breakdown.
  • Better mileage is provided by higher viscosity index, which controls oil use.
  • It lasts a long time and minimizes wear through friction.
  • The traditional oil from Valvoline also shields the car from Low-speed Pre-Ignition, and the container includes a precise pour outlet and an anti-glug tube.
  • It works with a wide range of automobiles.

Valvoline Durablend

All types of cars are well protected against corrosion and engine wear by Valvoline synthetic motor oils. The best product offered by Valvoline is Valvoline Durablend Motor Oil, which offers defense against sludge, wear, and oil breakdown.

Other synthetic compounds from Valvoline can be used in older vehicles with high mileage to help them function better and safeguard the engine against wear brought on by excessive heat and friction. The proper engine oil must be used in your vehicle! The incorrect oil can cause more harm than good.

Valvoline Full Synthetic

According to advertising, Valvoline full synthetic motor oil provides 40% more protection than other oils on the market. Well, the mixture includes high-quality anti-wear chemicals that cover the internal engine parts and offer protection for all important moving elements inside an engine.

Valvoline Synpower

Even in severe weather, Valvoline Synpower offers comprehensive protection. It does so because it is built to withstand extreme heat or cold. It is so adept at maintaining equilibrium. But oil can leak out at high temperatures. Additionally, it cannot evaporate when the chamber is heating up. It therefore has both advantages and disadvantages.

Key Qualities of Valvoline products

  • Synthetic oil from Valvoline keeps engines healthy and saves gasoline.
  • In every situation, Valvoline Advanced Full Synthetic SAE 0W-20 protects the engine. It is made to tolerate extremely hot or cold temperatures. Also a wonderful balancer is Valvoline 5w30 synthetic oil.
  • Additionally, as the chamber warms up, it cannot evaporate. The cost of Valvoline full synthetic oil is affordable, allowing everyone to purchase and use it.
  • Aside from that, Valvoline Full Synthetic High Mileage is the best option if you want a motor oil change that is both effective and reasonably priced. Several-litre bottles are also available. Consequently, you can use it repeatedly. These Valvoline engine oils therefore have a benefit over rival products.

Differences between Pennzoil vs Valvoline

General Differences

The primary variations between Valvoline and Pennzoil oils are shown below.

  • Using “enhanced” additives, Valvoline provides greater sludge, friction, and wear protection.
  • In cold temperatures, Pennzoil Platinum performs better than Valvoline and extends the time between oil changes.
  • Because Valvoline is strengthened for heavy-duty applications, you may use it for hardworking engines like toll vans and trucks.
  • When used in engines, Pennzoil Platinum helps to increase fuel efficiency.


Performance is the main factor that causes individuals to move from one brand of motor oil to another. Every car owner or driver wants the best motor oil to get the most out of the engine of his or her vehicle.

It’s interesting to note that the full synthetic alternatives from Valvoline and Pennzoil Platinum are both good lubricants with excellent performance. With one of these oils, you can run your engine at peak efficiency for 10,000 miles between drain intervals.

Since each of these oils comes in several grades, you must choose the one that satisfies the owner’s manual’s requirements for viscosity. However, PP flows better in low temperatures than Valvoline thanks to the PurePlus technology employed in it.

Protection of Engine & Fuel Economy

In general, full synthetic motor oils clean the engine more thoroughly than synthetic blends or traditional oils.

However, if you had to choose between Pennzoil Platinum and Valvoline, Pennzoil Platinum would result in a cleaner engine because the base oil is made from natural gas.

Valvoline, on the other hand, takes the lead when it comes to the overall protection of important engine components. Thanks to the “Premium” anti-wear compounds in the Valvoline formula, complete synthetic Valvoline offers a protective layer on top of crucial internal engine components to shield them from friction and excessive wear and tear.

On all modern engines, Pennzoil Platinum contributes to greater fuel efficiency than Valvoline.

Change Frequency

Valvoline doesn’t state the maximum distance between changes for its oil, however Pennzoil boasts that its Platinum motor oil can travel up to 10,000 miles. You might have to use PP over Valvoline if you want longer intervals between oil changes.

Despite this, Valvoline full synthetic motor oil can last over 7,500 miles while still providing good protection and efficiency because of the cutting-edge additives the company uses.

Pennzoil vs Valvoline: Our Recommendation

Now, with all these elements, maybe you did your choice. Or… You still wonder what to choose between Pennzoil vs Valvoline.

For us, the choice is clear:

  • Price is the first criterion, go for Pennzoil.
  • Quality is the first criterion, go for Valvoline.
  • Versatility matters to you (a good oil for any climate and any heat), go for Pennzoil.
  • You have a vehicle enduring heavy duty, go for Valvoline.

Pennzoil vs Valvoline: Product-by-product Reviews

Full Synthetic – Pennzoil vs Valvoline

Pennzoil Full Synthetic

Pennzoil Platinum/Ultra Platinum boasts being carbon-neutral and manufactured of natural gas. This makes it environmentally sustainable without sacrificing performance.

Pennzoil Platinum Full Synthetic 10W-30 Motor Oil (5-Quart, Single)

as of December 4, 2022 10:11 am

It offers a higher performance additive system to ease wear and safeguard the turbocharger.

Additionally, the motor oil defends against severe temperatures and complies with a strict industrial requirement. The pistons are kept 50% cleaner than the minimum industry standard by the Platinum/Ultra Platinum series.

Additionally, it complies with a wide range of requirements and approvals, including FCA MS 6395 and ISLAC GF-5.

Customers, however, have complained about the packing and the reduced fuel economy improvement. Due to the natural gas base, it is also highly expensive and does not condition older seals.

Valvoline Full Synthetic

Valvoline Extended Protection Full Synthetic Motor Oil SAE 5W-20 5-Quart

as of December 4, 2022 10:11 am

The Valvoline SynPower concentrates on varnish protection and sludge removal to facilitate engine cleanliness. It offers both good low-temperature protection and great high-temperature protection.

This is accomplished by facilitating a quicker and smoother oil flow upon startup. The Advanced version works with a variety of synthetic oils and supports fuel efficiency, volatility reduction, and evaporation protection.

Strong anti-wear additives are also included in SynPower to combat the main causes of engine stress and prolong their time in the oil circulation. The

Variants of SynPower/Advanced are appropriate for a wide range of passenger automobiles. However, the container’s construction is somewhat flimsy, and the pouring mechanism is once more inconvenient. The finest value is also provided by Valvoline.

High Mileage – Pennzoil vs Valvoline

Pennzoil Platinum High Mileage

Pennzoil Platinum High Mileage Full Synthetic 5W-30 Motor Oil for Vehicles Over 75K Miles (5-Quart, Single-Pack)

as of December 4, 2022 10:11 am

Given that the Platinum version is environmentally friendly, the Pennzoil/Pennzoil Platinum High Mileage is a respectable rival. It is carbon-neutral and made from natural gas. Both versions offer lower oil usage, wear protection, and turbocharger protection. Due to its unique makeup, it adds 550 miles more year.

The Platinum version additionally protects against extremely high temperatures while ensuring engine cleanliness. Additionally, it has the unusual ability to preserve HP in older automobiles. Older seal conditioners are also included in Pennzoil/Pennzoil Platinum, ensuring excellent performance and less leaks in older engines.

Although customers think the Platinum version is pricey, it also gets extremely good reviews and has demonstrable outcomes.

Due to its lack of a natural gas basis and nearly identical performance to the superior version, the standard variant is more cheap.

Valvoline High Mileage

Valvoline High Mileage 150K with MaxLife Plus Technology Motor Oil SAE 10W-30 5-Quart

as of December 4, 2022 10:11 am

The flagship product, Valvoline High Mileage with Maxlife Technology, comes in two varieties: entirely synthetic and synthetic blend. There are two sub-variants: one for engines with more than 75,000 miles on them, the other for those with more than 150,000.

Components of the high mileage oil include seal conditioners, detergents, and antioxidants. The aging engine seals are treated by the seal conditioners to effectively stop leakage.

Sludge and deposits are removed from old engines using detergents, which bind to them. By preventing engine blockage, antioxidants are essential for preventing breakdown. Additionally, it comes in various grades of viscosity.

The MaxLife technology significantly extends the life and performance of older engines and improves mileage when combined with Moly Additive protection.

Customers, however, continue to have issues with packaging. Due to its non-fully synthetic base, the synthetic blend variant is the most popular, but it also necessitates more frequent oil changes.

Both titans strive to keep their high-quality offerings in order to guarantee total customer pleasure. Pennzoil and Valvoline both seem like superior options sometimes, though.

In the end, it is down to the preferences and choices of the buyer since synthetic motor oil must be selected according to the type of vehicle.

Final words on Pennzoil vs Valvoline

In conclusion, this Pennzoil vs Valvoline comparison outlines the key distinctions between these two of the market’s top sellers. Pennzoil is more reasonably priced than Valvoline, cleans the engine more thoroughly, and still enables you to go for greater distances between oil changes.

Full synthetic Valvoline is more thicker, provides superior protection, and works even on engines that do difficult jobs on a daily basis. In conclusion, PP is best if you require more time between drain periods, and Valvoline is the preferred option if you want stronger protection.

Related Pages: